Freight Pricing: Who REALLY Holds the Power?
A new pricing index reveals that while freight brokers maintain a margin advantage over shippers, their leverage has decreased as market conditions shift toward capacity-driven tightening.
New data from rate management firm Tabi indicates that brokers and carriers currently maintain pricing leverage in the spot market, though this advantage is weakening. Reporting from FreightWaves highlights the TABI Pricing Pressure Index, which utilizes a 0-to-100 scale to measure market control. The index recently climbed seven points to a reading of 36, signaling that shippers are slowly gaining ground as conditions for service providers become less favorable compared to earlier in the year.
The index analyzes several factors including total load volumes and various margin types to determine where power sits. Tabi founder Rush Feldhacker noted that while brokers are still securing spot volumes with healthy margins, the current environment is significantly different than three months ago. Unlike demand-driven cycles, the current market is being shaped by capacity constraints, meaning brokers may see higher margins on individual loads without a corresponding increase in the total volume of freight available to move.
Shippers often experience these market transitions on a delay, typically feeling the impact three to four months after brokers notice a shift. This gap occurs because contract rates provide a temporary shield until service failures or tender rejections force shippers to confront higher costs. Feldhacker observed that many shippers fail to anticipate these changes, noting that some market participants previously mistook temporary soft conditions for "the new normal" even as data suggested a reversal was already underway.
Success in the latter half of the year will likely depend on how effectively brokers utilize data rather than relying on traditional intuition. The report suggests that firms analyzing win rates by specific lanes and customers are better positioned to handle upcoming volatility. Those who continue to chase volume without disciplined pricing strategies may struggle as the market moves away from the patterns seen in previous years, emphasizing the necessity of formal analytics in modern logistics.
Editorial Desk — Trade Flow Insight. Reporting and market notes compiled by the Trade Flow Insight editorial team.
Related coverage
FMCSA’s Elison addresses Motus again, still no date on full repair
Chattanooga–It hasn’t been that long–less than a month–since Jesse Elison spoke to an industry event and addressed the issue of the beleaguered new Motus registration system. The deputy administrator of the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) spoke Monday at FreightWaves’ Broker Compliance Symposium, one of two one-day sessions that serve as a prelude to the larger Future of Freight Festival here that begins Tuesday The biggest news in his presentation was really no news: after saying at the National Motor Freight Traffic Association in early October that FMCSA was “weeks away”
Mexican truckers launch national strike over highway security, rising costs
Mexican trucking companies launched an indefinite nationwide strike Monday protesting highway insecurity, cargo theft, extortion and rising operating costs, with demonstrations planned in major freight hubs along the U.S.-Mexico border. The strike, organized by the National Chamber of Freight Transportation (CANACAR) and other trucking organizations, calls for demonstrations across Mexico, including Nuevo Laredo, Reynosa, Monterrey, Tijuana and Mexico City. The protests could disrupt freight transportation through some of North America’s busiest commercial corridors, particularly in Nuevo Lare
Trump Administration Unveils Seafood Strategy to Boost U.S. Fishing Fleet and Domestic Production
The Trump administration on Friday unveiled its America First Seafood Strategy, outlining plans to strengthen the U.S. commercial fishing industry through regulatory reform, investment in fishing vessels and shoreside infrastructure,...